Best manpads reddit. And RBS-90 jeeps are just.
Best manpads reddit Syria has had a long history of arms transfers from Russia and Fmr. They need to change the interaction between manpads and Helis im fine with ka50 dropping hella flares and dodging a few… If they make MANPADs as good as they should be than nobody gonna be happy. Why not spend the few hours of workshop time to stick ‘em all together and ge sas are the best in the game. No manpads. You don’t have much time to make an engagement, measured in seconds. The GameSpy shutdown closed the official multiplayer, but fan alternatives have kept the online active ever since with thousands playing weekly into 2021+. 11e has I think the strongest INF in the game I think. Now that we have proof MANPADS have a measurable presence in Syria, the next question to ask is where the Syrian rebels got these MANPADS? Well, some of them are simply taken from Syria’s stockpiles. Or check it out in the app stores Ukraine Receiving RBS-70 NG Worlds Best MANPADS (2022) On the Source of MANPADS. 3. There are the usual countermeasures such as flares, but some MANPADS are more flare resistant, and aircraft only have a limited number of them. An additional angle has been released Add the MANPAD to the specialist role. Yes, a desperate enough air force would try to get this thing out in the field and just tell the pilot to limit g-forces and top flight speed, and basically just hope for the best. Welcome to /r/hoggit, a noob-friendly community for fans of high-fidelity combat… Ditch the gigantic, hand cranked autocannon and buy more MANPADs. Well, it's wiki having brain rot again. Workshop page of the mod, Manpads belong to the "Flak trooper" class that the mod adds, they are in the specialist role and therefor there is a team wide max amount of them. Most of the MANPAD related losses seem to have been caused by Iglas, Strelas and more modern systems like the Martlet and Starstreak. Enjoy learning all the nuances of DCS friend! Manpads are good in cities mainly, sometimes forests. the manpad starts from 0, has to accelerate to the jets speed, then has to accelerate to higher speed to catch up. Millennium Dawn's Divisions can be scary to look at and understand, but this should help you build up your military Note: this is based on the AI Divs For artists, writers, gamemasters, musicians, programmers, philosophers and scientists alike! The creation of new worlds and new universes has long been a key element of speculative fiction, from the fantasy works of Tolkien and Le Guin, to the science-fiction universes of Delany and Asimov, to the tabletop realm of Gygax and Barker, and beyond. ) SHORAD, however, is for some reason without S. Say: • 2 MBT coys, each with organic IFV-mounted MANPADs in the HQ section • 1 Mech Inf coy, with 30mm cannon • 1 Artillery coy with tracked 155mm or GMLRS • 1 Combat Eng coy with support gear etc • 1 Support coy (logistics, medical, signals etc) Doing best for your country's interest is wrong side of history? Pakistan is doing this because it's best for their own country as they not only can get another support internationally, can improve PR among their NATO support and get foreign currency that they desperately need. SAS, Lstr-40s, and the Finnish recce squad are the best manpads squads, all others are highly situational. A lot of people like to talk about how fighters like the F-35 are irrelevant because UAVs are the future since they are so much more maneuverable (truthfully, UAVs aren't at the same level of all around performance as a manned fighter yet), but really when you think about it, missiles are just suicidal UAVs that are much more maneuverable than any aircraft. I would not realistically expect manpads to take down cruise missiles. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. 1 miles (5km) to 3. SPAA is maybe good if you don't have air superiority but they're weaker than base game SPAA and you already get air attack from MANPADS. Takes care of both the armor threat and the air threat. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Still most are viable just anything with mistrals will have the best preformce. Russia does have air superiority, what they don't have is air supremacy. This will ensure that you will have the best possible chance to stay alive in those "Oh FUCK" moments. The sight of the MANPAD is maginified, once the missile is launched the targeted aircraft will get a warning to deploy flares, logi and attack helicopters have flares but Reddit link to footage. man pad teams need to be reduced significantly. Cruise missile would travel 1665 meters in 7. It's useful against pretty much everything in the air. MANPADS is very boring parsed with random seconds of excitement. 187 votes, 95 comments. generally MANPADs are pretty much impossible to maintain for non state actors, and they probably are also more fragile than ATGM's. Countermeasures can fool missiles but are not a certain success and good positioning can make them more effective. Saperzy Sturmozowi: Shock flamethrower teams are a deadly force in cities and forests alike, able to go toe to toe with even MG3 spam. Compared to "proper" air defense, manpads are pennies on the dollar. Pair them with autocannons or tanks for GREAT JUSTICE. This is a subreddit for War Thunder, a cross platform vehicular combat MMO developed by Gaijin Entertainment for Microsoft Windows, macOS, Linux, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X|S. Israel does have MANPADs with at least 250 FIM-92 and 1,000 FIM-43 that we know of Hi all, been playing for a couple days using the su25t and im on the second mission of the georgian oil war ATO A. *"being hit" was unintelligible* Second voice Ka-52: You're being shot at, coming from the left. They’re not gonna kill many planes but they’re good against helos if the enemy decides to bring them too close. Last time I checked the history on community issue/bug tracker, there were at least 5 duplicate or related (e. Word from the recent conflict in Ukraine is that proliferation of modern manpads has basically made the airspace under 15k feet impassable, and helicopters and planes are flying literally at treetop level. This generally applies to helicopters, aircraft taking off or landing, or A-10s / F-35 / Su-25 / F-16 / whatever performing a Close Air Support role. Correction it is an Ka-52. 3 so they would be compete with rolands for place in line-up. The best close-range AT launcher in the world. TBH I think it would be best to go the ultra realistic route, however people might get fed up with that seeing as PR and Squad are both bridges between casual FPS and hardcore milsim. The closer the missile get's launched at the target, the less flares work basically. Sounds more like you're getting shot in the ass by manpads vs being hit in the wing / sides being defensive against SA-8. We are at war, so content is tightly moderated to keep our community safe. One thing the AI seems much better about, is massing units in an area to defend; one thing the AI seems very bad at, is counter attacking with those units in a push. In my tests, rate of flaring makes the most difference. For fast jets, not so much. The best long-range AT launcher in the world. MANPADS hardly carry much explosives, and they have been shown to not even be terribly reliable at bringing down multirole jets on a hit - planes that are much smaller and more compressed. Gen 1 (SA-7, Redeye)were designed to target hot metal. Ambushing helos and airplanes from unexpected positions. So the cruise missile had a 900 meter head start. Where are you going to put the Carl Gustaf with their new laser guided projectile developed between Saab and Raytheon? Capable of being fired from enclosed spaces. My question is mainly focused on fixed wing aircraft. IR missiles with range about 4 nm and max altitude about 14k' AGL. TL;DR: Yes, they are dangerous sometimes. Even if your MANPADS comes in with an HMG-armed transport, it's handy to have depth to your air defense. Look at this gentleman here writing MANPADS with an S. Pretty much all manpads have a contact or graze fuze, stinger, igla, strella,and grom, while star-streak has only contact fuze, they try their best to directly hit the target but if they don't they burst as close as they can get Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Ukraine Receiving RBS-70 NG Worlds Best MANPADS (2022) youtube. When the air threat is down then the MANPADs can just switch back to machine gunner or engineer, w/e. Generally very effective but with caveats. 04. 3 and i manage to maybe make one strafe then just bam ouy of no where those pesky randomly placed manpads get me. The main issue is the limited range of a man transportable system. All MANPADs spaa will get higher br and they will be 10. They could perhaps do a split where heavier transport helos and attack helos have MAWS where lighter ones don't, AND the missiles need minor set up. Hey! So me and my friends have had this problem, against manpads you cant do a whole lot except strike first (Ai will generally spawn bunched up) and depending on the type of AA it has an arming range so flying low and fast usually works. Even ancient MANPADS are taking down top tier fighters inc su-35. It's the same with ATGM teams. As long as a hit doesn't destroy a structurally critical spot, or cause the loss of all steering (which honestly sounds like a design flaw in the first place MANPADS are around 1700 mph (750 meters per second), which is 3. Write MANPADS with an S, always. Like others said, have a wingman for an extra set of eyes, expect it and preflare or best case, stay above them, usually 12,000 to 14,000 feet above the ground should keep you safe. The CMS or counter measure system is a great tool, but truly understanding how it works and its limitations is huge. So lets talk about MANPADs. r Just looking for a balanced MANPADS mod that isn't able to one shot aircraft from across the map with a missile that flies at several times the speed of sound. That's the correct way to do it, because the S in MANPADS is for 'system', not plural. It is my understanding that MANPADS present a serious threat to low flying aircraft and helicopters. Most missing accurate lock ranges and maneuverability. 7K subscribers in the UPSCpreparation community. In multiplayer your wingman can immediately engage the MANPADS with clusterbombs or even his gun. The extra 400m range makes a huge difference for manpads, worth the 10 points imo. You'll need both HATs and MANPADs on the field at the same time. Grom/Promet for life. A jet 10km over ground dropping GPS guided bombs is pretty much safe from MANPADS. Battlefield 2 is a 2005 PC game developed by DICE. I am however unsure about how careful you have to be with MAD-4 launchers, especially if they have the MAD-4A missiles. Flares are the most effective when you deploy them before they launch the missile at you because they make it nearly impossible to get a decent infrared lock but obviously they can distract the missile mid flight as well. Though it’s likely an Mi-17. I felt the format of reddit is better for discussion and… I mean, what you're doing wrong is flying low altitude in an area with half a dozen manpads. Allegedly the shoot down occurred through the use of MANPADS. idk something because right now sead doesnt matter, if you want to Millennium Dawn is a mod for Hearts of Iron IV that aims to change the originally World War 2 setting to be one of the Modern Era. I've seen Roman candles, bottle rockets and redneck built potato guns that were more accurate. And now highly capable anti-ship missiles. The real question, though, is why the Igla has identical seeker performance to the Stinger, despite stinger having wildly improved seeker technology IRL. They cost more but will pay for themselves 3x over with the first heli they shoot down. Looks like they've used up all their first world munitions and for those who believe Ukraine is losing, feel free to check out combat footage page, showing how effective a $1700 drone and a single grenade can be against a four million dollar T-90. Ukrainian Soldiers fired a MANPADS Man - Portable - Air - Defense - System (Essentially a small missle meant to take down larger missiles) And successfully took down a Russian cruise missle heading for Civilian Space. It requires some practice but without a JTAC it's the only way to effectively clear an area of MANPADS. These units miss A LOT whenever I deploy them. 15 votes, 27 comments. Jesus, man. It's been reported multiple times. Atgms also work great but because helos can be a bit laggy and desync sometimes the atgm doesn't do any damage upon impact (happened 2 out of 3 times for me recently). 1. Because of sekrit documents, Harrier flies at 1200 km/h. Starburst is in the game and is far and away the best MANPADS of any nation. 2 MANPADs and 2 HATs per team. I never take a single Manpad team because I know they will run out of missiles before they take down a single heli. All sent to support Ukraine. I agree that the AI feels much better than Wargame, but that it still has some glaring weaknesses. They are effective in the sense they offer any air defense capability. Also be prepared to reclass to 14P since the Army plans on expanding ADA. Sometimes, it misses at the last second. (Same for AWACS. The heaviest weaponry CAS aircraft were facing in Vietnam were usually HMGs or 20mm flak cannons, hence the heavy armor. Also, obviously we would get the CAS variants back if they added Manpads, wtf do you mean by scouting tools we already have heli cams for co-pilots, you didn't even mention the biggest sin of helis right now and that is logistics/transportation (we need heli slings and fast ropes) before fucking "mOaR gUnS," and I don't know And RBS-90 jeeps are just silly, for the price. That's kinda the point of manpads. Yeah but i mean, ive only seen the mistral missiles getting shot from a platform in a stationary position or a vehicle, i mean if it can be shoulder fired, like the Stinger or the Igla, ive searched for images of it being shot in that way but i cant seem to find any, soo thats where my doubt started. It is mainly developed by a small group of modders, but everybody is welcome to contribute to the project as long as they are sticking to the principle of quality. This was, necessity being the mother of invention, due to their extremely limited budgets and the unavailability of the best tech from abroad. Whenever I shoot at a tank, the missile gives me its best space rocket impression and launches itself to mars. GROM: It's only the best MANPADS in the game. They don't need to gain much altitude necessarily, and relatively level combat allows the missile to glide easily after the rocket engine burns out Strela is not the Strela MANPADS, it's a full-fat missile like the MIM-72. Sometimes they would go after hot windows or rocks. When the best fixed-wing missiles were AIM-9Es and best heli missiles were R-60Ms and AIM-9Ls, having these small missiles be as good as the helicopter missiles of the MI-24V/P and AH-1Z was a problem. Reddit's (not so new) home for defense themed shitposts. This is the only reason hypersonics are being developed. Sounds to me like Russia is scared. Flares are nice but in every vid I've seen it launched at the wrong time or the aircraft was too low to take advantage against the high angle trajectory of the rockets. The Redfor air defenses, MANPADS, SA-9 and SA-13 are all basically the same missiles in DCS in terms of performance. This subreddit has voted to go private as part of a joint protest to Reddit's recent API changes, which breaks third-party apps, accessibility tools, and moderation tools, effectively forcing users to use the official Reddit app. All he needs to do is dump flares while engaging the MANPADS to reduce the distance at which the MANPADS can lock on to him. It was pretty hard to understand. Best to keep the transports near to move them if needed because they're super slow. The best way to kill a helo is to shoot it with a tank. So i have a question, where anti-aircraft aerial defense is concerned, are AA guns in the style of CIWS cannons more effective than MANPADS? One thing I thought of is that MANPADS are going to be lighter, and easier to carry around, while AA guns are heavy and require towing. that's why for SAM system adapted from AAM they have to add an additional solid booster to for modern MANPADs, it’s usually around 6 miles (10km) for detection and 4 miles (6km) for engaging, with a max engagement altitude of 20,000 feet (6,100m); this particular model is over 40 years old, so its range varies from 3. I had the experience with Stingers and TOW's to compare but I imagine the same goes for others ATGM's vs MANPADs. 99K subscribers in the hoggit community. They can be mounted on two tanks, and the Koreans have a limited supply of ManPads to start equipping their rather massive Tank fleet (that would be about 1000 ManPads for the P-Ho alone). man pads combined with sam and aaa is just absolute area denial, either this or there should be an option to fly jets high above man pad range like in real life but expose them to sam net and aaa sooner. They're ir tracking missiles like manpads (they're slightly larger than manpads I believe but use the same system) And that jeep is so fucking useless thanks to the bugged missile a god damn milk truck is more of a threat to a heli. MANPAD's require batteries that are rare and have a limited life span. While it's clear that the Kurdish people are facing a serious threat, I'm wondering why they haven't purchased 9K32 Strela-2 MANPADS (Man-Portable Air Defense Systems) to defend themselves against these attacks. If you can get a cruise missile to reach speeds above Mach 5 paired with accurate terminal guidance then not even these fast anti-air missiles will be fast enough to intercept. UK helicopters get hidden ECM stats and TOW 2. High HP, great weapons and some of the best ATRL in the game available en mass. 0 minimum and more like 10. If you buy a crap load of manpads and spread them out amongst your infantry and shorad, you've made one heck of a deterrent. Time from launch of MANPADS (0:06) to impact (0:09+) was about 3. Business, Economics, and Finance. I’m genuinely shocked we haven’t seen more airliners downed with manpads. r Okay, yes, manpads need to be better, but that’s not related to a stat card advertised range. 7 miles (6km) depending on the variant. Manpads have a habit of surprising you and taking rear aspect shots, whilst the sa-8 will shoot at your front usually. In my last game i could not lock a f86 with a mistral at 400m because the smoothbrain devs balance cas by lowering clouds to 10m, i just cant anymore Then I was reading about MANPADS downing Russian helicopters in Ukraine. Mainly effective against helos, especially longbow since it won't see them while it's getting shot at. (I made a typo, that's supposed to be Ka-52 not Ka-50. they were originally intended to allow smaller units to The Mistrals are the current best ground launched misslies, but like all Ground launched heat-seekers they are still not modeled correctly some like mistrals are missing irccm. First voice Ka-52: Whoa, that building's been hit. If a Stugna-P can credibly down Helicopters with a LASER from an emplaced system, Carl G should also be a MANPADS. Soviet Union. In this case, though, I think the aircraft would probably be worth more as parts, and the pilot much better used in a fully functional airframe. The default hornet flaring profile of like 2 per second is almost useless against manpads. The newer verba MANPADS are seen with IFF antennas that look similar to the ones on stingers, but I don't think I've ever seen an igla with one; it would be off to the side like a stinger one, or over the top. Preparation for UPSC examination. Crypto Its more a matter of tuning. Recently, there have been reports of Turkish air strikes targeting Kurdish areas in Iraq and Syria. upvotes r/weaponsystems. So long story short, in the 18 there is no way to be warned of an IR missile launch except visually. MANPADS can be effective against fighter jets if they are "low & slow & near". MANPADS weren't largely in US armories at the time, and were hardly even a concept for a country as dependent as North Vietnam. 3K votes, 306 comments. Helicopters are much better at dissipating heat than an after burning plane, and it’s not like you fire an aim-9J at 6+km just because the stat card says the missile can theoretically fly that far. They're no replacement for proper IADS, but by god are MANPADS a nightmare to fight against. The flying mechanics although not perfect definitely aren't that bad. I think all the Ka-50s, of which there were only like 20, have been converted to 52s) Modern attack helos generally outrange MANPADS 2-3 times over even in ideal conditions for the MANPAD (ideal MANPAD range is ~5km whereas Ka-52s can do 15-18 km with the Vikhr afaik). Manpads are a massive danger to low flying aircraft. Casualties are unknown, as is the helicopter make. 359K subscribers in the NonCredibleDefense community. Levels of the same concept and operationally different. Second best is the Strela-10m2. manpads are small, they dont have that much fuel to accelerate forever. Yes and no depending on the angle and range. This would exclude mods such as the MANPADS Thing or the ADU-59 Slinger as both are kind of broken in this regard and usually result in aircraft being shot down within 10 seconds of takeoff. MANPADS are short range, so can only target aircraft which are nearby and low down. Modern missiles are much harder to fool but earlier missiles are much easier. One of the best MANPADS in the game (2800 range, 55% accuracy), mounted on a wheeled platform for fast response, with a good enough supply of missiles, and a twin launcher for good burst, for only 35 points. Iraq, Syria and Libya all stockpiled the shit out of Soviet models and in the case of Syria and Iraq you actually saw foreign models coming in (ironically from Sudan in the case of the FN-6). MBTs and SPGs have too little org/hp, can be pierced by IFVs anyways, will ruin your terrain bonus, and will slow down your IFV divisions. So despite the theoretical max range of the MANPADS, you really gotta be right under the flight path with a decent prior warning to be able to intercept even a subsonic cruise missile. 4 times faster. I've seen a few people commenting here and in general deck guides that MANPADS aren't worth one of the five inf slots in an unspecialised deck. add to the fact that this combo house's the fastest moving infantry you can easily bug out after whaling on someones units and avoid any counter-indirect Another consideration is that certain models of MANPADS require the seeker head to be cooled before it can lock on to a thermal source, which adds time. MANPADS are extremely rare amongst the various EAOs and have only been deployed a handful of times in the past two years. i kill everyones airforce by midgame by just spamming 30 man pad teams. Stinger Block 2 is vastly improved. Simple as that. I'm a fairly new player, only lvl 16, but for me a card of good MANPADs is basically an auto-include. type-93 and ozelot use the same firing mechanism) reports and a few other related (mostly for aircraft) (I had checked for duplicates/etc. They can break Mach 2 in optimal conditions. Gen 2 (SA-14, SA-16, first stingers) were programmed to track the heat signature of a turbine engine. One of the best MANPADs in the world. g. Hence, Gaijin gutted and gimped them. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now Ukraine Receiving RBS-70 NG Worlds Best MANPADS (2022) youtube. And helis with good MANPADs will be almost invincible for most planes so less counter vs heli spam. Time from cruise missile overhead (0:02) to launch of MANPADS (0:06) is 4 seconds. 35 YA has some super strong inf too + more ATGM, but the fact that spetnaz can’t kill tanks means the micro can get a little complicated. The 145s are great especially against SAAWs (stay at least 20k feet above ground) and IRAPCs (stay at least 15k feet above ground, same for manpads). They could and did perform extreme acts of computing on extremely limited hardware. 30w light infantry for garrisons. Be like u/youreon3rdst. Nov 23, 2021 · One strategy I've devised is to stack cheap F&F MANPADS in a forest where the enemy frequently flies planes or helicopters over for sudden surprise attacks or damage. My best advice is to pump out 8-10 flares in quick succession right as the manpad fires. Its an extremely difficult thing to do apparently as the MANPADS needs to be manually aimed and then follows a heat signature. Here's my version. The beam riders like Star Streak and RBS-70 are essentially un-jammable but require terminal optical guidance from the CLU. Minstrels are arguably the best manpads blufor gets. In the range MANPADS are mostly designed for, visual/optical recognition is good enough in most cases These are disadvantages (you can probably find others as well) that makes radars simply not worth it for such short range missiles, the shortest range of widely used radar guided SAMs are in the 10km range (for example SA-8). Dedicated A2A missiles (aim9, R-73/60M, etc) are tuned for that situation, they inherit a lot of speed from the launch aircraft, so they're typically faster with a lot more range for relatively low thrust rocket motors. (u/I_Slay_Dragons_AMA) Ozelot doesn't use manpads If you want to see how fucking useless these tanks will be in game look at the type 93. HERE УКРАЇНА TAKES CENTER STAGE — The purpose of r/Ukraine is to amplify Ukrainian voices. Most Light attack craft mounting manpads would have no air defences at all as most of them are equipped with radars for surface engagements. Yea the best are usually if you can get two units capable of engaging helos with one purchase. Buy more MANPADS, sure, but it’s not either/or. Be a gentleman. so I could link up the evidence together, since the new public issue tracker does not support uploads for Posted by u/AceAxos - 11 votes and 31 comments Today, in the direction of Zaporizhzhia, a National Guard fighter shot down a Russian Mi-8 helicopter with the help of an Igla MANPADS, NSU reports. I helped create the Stinger MANPADS course for non-ADA troops and I’ll tell yeah, having they extra bit of training for infantry and cavalry soldiers goes a long way to add protection to the forward line of troops. Funnily enough, Mistrals were and still are the best MANPADS in the game, they're the only ones that have a better G-overload and track rate, while every other MANPADS all have exactly the same overload and track rate. Fighter jets are incredible machines but guided rockets changed everything. You already have lots of these old autocannons in inventory, lots of these jeeps as well, and no shortage of manpower since you’re China. pair them with seals in cities and forests and its an unstoppable combo since the sas make for a tough weapons and manpads team where the seals are anti infantry. Only thing Id change is bringing minstrels over stingers. Everything about the ARMA game series by Bohemia Interactive on reddit! Game updates, videos, pictures, discussions, help, and more. 5 seconds. Surprisingly this seems to be their main Posted by u/Candid-Squirrel-2293 - 19 votes and 12 comments However, the initial claim was that the ManPads were mounted on all tanks « since the 70’s », which is simply wrong. . Manpads are very dangerous for helis. A ground attack plane slowing down to a few hundred kph at a few hundred meters could be a potential target. texsngs uotlk crr ltzf yeip xtmzc wgj ighfp luux oaxwx