Difference between remington 209 and winchester 209 primers. 243 stepped, most consistent in size Win.

Difference between remington 209 and winchester 209 primers It appears that the STS is an improved version of the Remington Premiere and the only difference I can see is the flash hole is smaller on the Per Remington: "New 209 Premier STS primers can be substituted for Remington's previous 209P primers without changes in published We are here to talk about primers. 15 That's why I assume $192. I shoot Winchester 209 primers and I might have 1 or 2 that miss-fire out of a hole box. $69. 3k They are all manufactured by the SAME company (or at least owned by. " According to the Remington ammo plant, their so-called new 'Kleanbore' primer is the same old 209-4 . Generally, load data calling for a Federal 209A primer will use less powder than the same load data using a Winchester 209 primer. I started online shopping for some and every site, i found is "out of stock" for any brand of muzzleloader primers. If I use a 209M to ignite a low-power 7/8-oz Cowboy action At that pressure I wouldn't worry. Increase the propellant weight to 22 grs. 140, primers are . 209 primer 1140 fps @ 7,900 LUP Same load except with the Federal 209 primer for 1160 fps @ 9,000 LUP. Remington Gun Club hull Winchester W209 primer 18 grains of Clay Dot Claybuster CB1100-12 wad 1oz Eagle Magnum 7. Thanks for any help you can offer. 209, but with 2 grains less 540 powder. i called T/C and asked them what primer and they recommended CCI primers Winchester Primers 209 Shotshell (Box of 1 000) $82. I tried Remington and Winchester muzzleloader primers. If you make the leap between the Winchester and Remington primer, you'll have a shell that performs differently. 71 cents/25 for Winchesters. 0 grs I can't explain the differences between similar or identical loads documented by At that pressure I wouldn't worry. Re: shotgun 209 primers vs Win 777 209s. Winchester 209mz in my cva wolf spits sparks out of the barrel just like cheddites do. Can't seem to find data unless I use a Federal primer. CCI 209 Primer vs Winchester 209 Primer. The "Muzzleloader 209 Primer" is a salesman's shuffle. 244* * measurements taken by someone else The stepped, meaning smaller front, makes it easier for the primer to enter the opening. I was running out of waa209 and loaded a few boxes using the same data and used cheddite primers instead. Clark St. Never had a problem with standard 209 primers. That's a sweet, tight load, BTW. 7 gr with the W209 primer at 10,000 psi. The 97* primer was a target grade primer, mild and was competitive to the Winchester 209 or CCI 209 Trap & Skeet of the day. Only Fed209A and CCI209M are hot primers, all the rest are moderate. There is a difference. Winchester works to make sure all primers are reliable, instant and precise. If the Remington primers were closer in price. Nice feature. Current data Federal 209_A_ primer drops to 17. For the 1 1/8 oz load Rem Fig 8 wad it takes 19. Which is better for muzzleloading, large rifle primers or 209 primers? There are many different types of muzzleloader ignition systems out there. THe 209 Fed primer was very close in strength to a W-209, and could be substituted for the W-209 without problems. I notice no difference in accuracy between the brands but do notice slightly higher velocities with the hotter primers. CCI, Federal or Winchester 209 primers which ever is cheaper. No primer has fallen out. Fiocchi's and Cheddites, and IIRC Nobelsport primers are all a bit larger than Win/Rem 209's. That day came and I started trying the Cheddite’s. The CCI 209M is much hotter than the Win 209 and is more on a par with the Fed 209A. 0 grs. 0 Grains of Hodgdon Clays: Wad: Winchester WAA12L: They seem to be close to the Winchester W209, so if you started out with such a load and modified it (dropped 1/2 grain) like I described previously, you'd probably be OK. It is not consistent. Recently I ran out of Win 209 primers and I substituted a couple hundred CCI 209 primers that I had left from several years ago. Extensive testing with a variety of commonly-used reloading powders has shown that new 209 Premier STS primers, in comparison with other commonly-used primers, WINCHESTER 209 SHOTSHELL PRIMER W209. I do use an o/u, so maybe different in a semi. The old 'Winchester Components Catalog, 14th Edition' shows this interesting 28 Gauge comparison of the difference between Federal 209 and Federal 209A primers with Win 540 Powder (HS-6), but unfortunately it is intermixing LUP and PSI. I doubt if you'll find any Red Dot/1 ounce loads using the Remington primer in the Winchester AA hull. Right or Wrong, safe/unsafe. Reply. 410 shotshell primers which helped with T7 loose powder, but were not reliable with T7 pellets. Sorry Driftwood but that's what I've found; . and Cheddite primers are all pretty close wrt brisance, and I doubt you'd see much difference in velocity. I chronographed Fed. We never recommend substituting primers, however if you choose to use a Cheddite primers in lieu of the Winchester you will probably see less pressure and velocity as the Cheddite primer is a ‘cooler’ primer than the Winchester. They are owned by the same company as Fed and CCI. Winchester - WSP. Shotgun Magnum I was surprised to see some Cheddite primer listings in the 1-1/8 oz section, the first time I had seen any data for them. e. The newer Win hulls have a seperate base wad. 79: In-Stock: Notify Me: Drifters Gear: Federal 209A Champion Shotshell 209 Primers 1000 total packed 10 boxes of 100. They don't appear to enlarge the primer pockets enough to cause a loose fit for the Winchesters. Have never seen a And, man, I've used all different kinds of 209 primers and can't tell a lick of difference between 'em, i. Choose Options. In fact, the folks that manufacture Blackhorn 209 specifically recommend NOT using 209 muzzleloading primers like these for most reliable ignition. Thank you gentlemen, I too swap Ched's with Winchester 209 primers but my question was about subbing Ched with CCI209, not Win's or CCI209M's. Since I use a Mec Sizemaster I am not worried about the primer pocket since it can be resized and Cheddite hulls can then take the Win 209's I have in I am not looking for reloading recipes only information on the differences between the two primers and if they can be exchanged. Have some Remington STS I picked up during the primer shortage but haven't worked up any loads with those, I was able to purchase several thousand Cheddite 209 primers and several thousand Federal 209A primers. Primers were visually equivalent, though we have no way of measuring the actual performance. The load consists of 15. 244 * Nobelsport type 209/686 . Load data for shotshells is very specific and there is not a lot of room for deviation from it. Rio's through my Ohler Chrono shot all with same tube wad just diffenent primer shot 5 shells each Rio's and Fed were closest Win. Quack Shot. Can I safely CCI 209, win 209, and rem 209p/sts are fine to swap with each other. I've been using the CCI 209 primers for my lower pressure reloads for use in my English SXS's using 25gr of 800X with winchester cases and Claybuster CB 1118-12 1 1/8oz of shot according to the IMR reloading website this load give around 1200fps with under 7000psi Winchester 209 Primers. Remington - 1½. Perusing my old Lyman books, it reveals that the Fed 209's , the 410's, the CCI 209's and the Win 209's, all delivered essentially the Cheddite 209 . The only difference was the plating used. 209P primer. Hodgdon 700X data only list the 617 primer. CCI 209, or CCI 209M? Huge difference between the two. Comments please thanks My go-to primer is Win 209, but some of my buddies use because you already have the go ahead from Alliant to sub in the Win primer for the Rem, it will be OK to sub in the Cheddite primer as (I That comes to 58. Skull : Thank you BP: 9/17/2021: Just purchased Cheddite 209 shotshell primers and it is so refreshing that you kept your price point close to pre-covid and pre I know it's the "wrong" answer but with all my sissy loads I have absolutely no issues with interchanging a Cheddite primer anywhere a Winchester is called for. Can't tell any noticable difference if any in the power difference between the different hulls. Plain 209 Remington's were made back in the early 80's for a short time, and are considerably hotter than today's STS primers. 410 specific primer sandwiched in there somewhere too which I still have a few of. thinking about getting them since i can't find any winchester large rifle primers. difference is that rem vs win i couldn't believe how much fouling you get from a 209 primer till i run a patch down my barrel after firing just a primer. Winchester - WMGSP. Winchester marketed 209 "muzzleloading primers," but all they were was standard W209 primers in more expensive packaging. These primers are all weaker than standard shotshell 209 primers and do not provide adequate ignition for Blackhorn 209 – especially when used in a poorly designed breech plug system. , 209 primers in stock, 209 primers in stock now, 209 primers walmart, 209 shotgun primer, amz-99-wlr, cci 209 primers amazon, difference between 209 and 209a primers, inline muzzleloader primers, muzzleloader primers, precision reloading, primers for sale Remington Small Rifle Bench Rest Primers #7-1/2 Box of But for the 2-3/4" high and low brass loads that I have worked up for my guns, I see no appreciable difference between using either Federal or Winchester or even CCI 209 primers. Some primers should not be used in certain cartridges. Winchester 209s. Winchester and Federal primers seem to have the edge on velocity retention and consistency. The difference in length between the 2 is about . GOD, Family, career However, I'm dealing with a very practical situation &#8230; I've simply been unable to find Winchester 209 primers locally, and I've finally come to the bottom of the last Winchester box. but I can't find any supporting data that there was yet another different Rem 209 primer being used or on the market at that time, other than the Rem 209T (target primer), NobelSport (Martignoni) 209 style Primers come in 3 different types: #684, #686 and #688. The 209-P is not made any more. My experience is that the CCI 209 is MILDER than the Win 209 primer. I have heard that CCI 209 (NOT CCI 209M) primers generally give slightly lower pressures vs. Shotgun Reloading question: How much difference is there in Federal 209 and 209A Primers for reloading! Why did they change the chemical make up. I refuse to use Cheddite, Winchester 209 tend to be "hotter" than Rem 209's. 10 days. The Fed. Neither did anything for the 777 crud ring. RWS. 99: Remington Primer 209 Premier Sts Shotshell 5000/case. 99. 140, and they fall out,of pocket! Is there a larger dia. 8 gr with the CH primer at 11,400 psi and 16. Advise if you have any recipes. Probably for 20 years. I''ve settled with CCIm, Win 209, and Fed209As. 4 - 15. 99: OUT: BT's comments on the difference between the CX1000 and CX2000 were important since I have heard of variances between cheddite once fired hulls using the CX2000 vs. 99 - $344. If you are using 777 conventional wisdom states that the muzzleloader 209s My experience with CCI 209 is with Red Dot powder and Rem STS hulls. The 209s labeled as muzzleloader are not as hot as the standard 209s. Depending on the load I use the WW 209, CCI 209, Federal 209, (notice I did not write 209A) and the Cheddites interchangeably. It can be seen that the maximum velocity difference between the various primers was 34 FPS. What do you guys think of RIO 209 Primers? but there was a MARKED difference in recoil and report between the Rio primers and the WW209s with the same loadings otherwise. The inline primers aren’t as hot as regular 209 primers. " The model 209/686 is the one Want to load Green Dot in a Federal Gold Medal hull and a Windjammer wad with 1 1/8 oz of shot. , and the Win. I looked on the Alliant website and they only list the Fed 209 data with Steel powder. I want to make him an offer to take all of them, but my buddy isn't sure these are Federal 209 or 209a primers. REMINGTON 209 PRIMERS . I've read, and I now believe, that a full power 209 has enough ooomph to start to move the pellets and bullets before the 777 pellets have burned completely. What surprised me was that for Rem hulls, using WAA12 wads, and looking at the 1145 fps listings, they showed 15. Don Fischer. Any help will be appreciated. My dad just bought his muzzleloader and he decided to go with the Remington 209 primers and out of about 30 primers, I had about 10-12 of them miss-fire. I got through 25 before saying "enough". The test load is the same as my normal target load, with the exception of the primer. I load one more difference in presure that the difference between a WW 209 and a Cheddite enthusiasts including the Remington, Beretta, and Mossberg I also bought 5000 Remington STS primers from Cabela's, retail, when they had fee shipping. I am using new hulls with plastic basewad and 209 primers, the old loads are listed as low pressure loads in the 8-9Kpsi range. I’m using the gray AA hull. 49 and btw they still go bang I’m not reloading shotgun shells anymore but I’ve Shopping for the Remington Shotshell Primer - Learn more about the latest Primers and other hunting or shooting gear at Remington. Black Powder - Winchester Triple Seven Primers VS Winchester W209 Primers - are the Same? I have a CVA Wolf Magnum and See alot of recommendations for Winchester W209 Primers. They are close but different - rising the term "hotness" of primers. The CCI 109 primers I have are Nickel plated and have the same ballistics as the 209 primers that is the only difference. if using green dot drop half a grain going from win/cci/rem primers up to fed 209a/CCI 209M. Notify Me: Grafs: Federal Primer 209a Shotshell 1000/box. All three of them use Remington Shells and Primers exclusively. $73. Question: How much more "oomph" do the 209M primers have over standard 209's? Hodgdon recommends 209M for 30-34 grains of Longshot pushing 1-1/8 oz shot to >1400 fps. With brass, bullet and powder the same in 308 Winchester, they tested velocity and pressures using Federal, Winchester, Remington and two different types of CCI primers to demonstrate the difference in performance among primers. Dogmeat Dad, SASS #48563L. Save Share Like. I have been using nothing but Winchester 209 primers in Remington STS hulls for years. I was wondering if I can use my All three types of primers are avaiable today. I have never used a Remington primer in my entire reloading career but only them. Claybuster lightnings and 7/8 and 1oz AA clones plus factory Remington and Winchester wads. I used Remington . DLM Win. I got 5,000 of the Cheddites at a great price. The Lyman 3rd has the most relevant data, but the Lyman 2nd shows the difference also. Careful with that. Save Share In the loading data I have studied, there is often a big difference between Remington 209P primers (one of the coldest on the market)compared to Federal 209A primers (the hottest). The Cheddite is a larger primer than the Winchester. There is no 209P STS primer. The new primer made by Remington is the Rem STS 209. 91/2 primers and no other manufacturer. But different wads will also result in different pressures. That said, I have found that Cheddite 209 primers most closely replicate Remington 209's in trap loads. I did find a marked difference between the cheddite's and the last 5000 fiocchi primers I had. 240-. Not sure if it is the black and red color that tells them apart, but its is one possible reason for the difference in those two colored Cheditte primers. 5 gr of Clays or Claydot. Based on this we are using the guideline that if pressures fall between 6500 - 8500 PSI, a primer swap is allowed. , they all go bang. The differences between the two primers are: – The number of digits in the primer number. As for wads and primers, they seem to be pretty much as advertised. Dave . after summer skeet I will go back and try . Joined CCI 209 Magnum Primers Similar to the Federal 209A primers, the CCI209M primers are more powerful, less expensive, but slightly dirtier than the Winchester 209 primers. Since I’m running out of Winchester primers, I called Alliant and spoke to a tech regarding substituting a different primer for the Winchester 209’s. target load with 17. Went to order some more and noticed Midsouth doesn't carry either. no differance on paper that i could see but my breach plug was dirtier than with a winchester 209. T. . I was wondering why there was a large stack of no. You should know how to tell the difference between a 209 and 209A shotgun primer. Hello everyone, This would be for 308 out of a bolt gun. I have found loads with the components I have for a CCI209M but not the standard CCI209. The question asked in the topic heading was answered by BT and DDC along with providing useful information about subbing the Ched's with the Win's. i shoot triple seven an they make a triple 7 primer so i tried some. Looking at our load data and using your components (Remington hull, CB1034-20, Remington 209P primers (used in testing) and velocities between 1200 -1250 FPS, the charges of 20/28 propellant would be 14. The difference between single and double based powders when it comes to lighting them off is, Winchester uses the same 209s for their . Will 209 shotshell primers work, magnum or regular. What year was this done! I know that this is a little off normal topic, but there Remington 209P, Winchester 209, Federal 209A, and CCI209M primers are all under the rubrik of "magnum primers. A first ballpark approximation would position the Cheddite 209 roughly between the Win 209 and the Federal 209A on average. Thanks for any info you can provide. 240-243 stepped Fiocchi 616 . 59 each Price: $187. Out of my dad's encore they do not. 243 stepped, most consistent in size Win. You are 100 percent on the difference in primers. I I have four different loads in the freezer right now, waiting for chronographing. I am trying to determine the primary difference Log in or Sign up. I am using the Winchester 777 muzzleloading primers, what i have left. He let me have them at a very good price so I bought them. Win. I am wondering what to expect regarding pressure and performance with the same wad/powder/powder charge but in the new hulls and a 209 primer. Win and Rem hulls (especillay the older compression formed hulls) are basically the same. The common ones sold here are the 688's. There's even an audible difference. More options are always good in our opinion but it can make things a little confusing and that's If you are at a high pressure level with Remington primers, where does Winchester 209 primers fit in the hotness scale?---Matt</i> but there is not much difference between the CCI-M and F209A primer, and RedDot and Promo burn the same. Use the same load but substitute the Fed. I recently purchased an 8 pound container of Hodgdon 700X and 2000 Fiocchi 616-209 primers. 5 cents/25 for Cheddites vs. 4 grains Clays powder, WAA12SL wads, in Win AA hulls. The question I have concerns the Federal 209 primers. 10tenner . seems to be working for me. Red Dot Remington RXP12 wad Win. Win and Rem hulls (especillay the older compression formed hulls) are basically the Looking at our load data and using your components (Remington hull, CB1034-20, Remington 209P primers (used in testing) and velocities between 1200 -1250 FPS, the difference is that rem vs win 209's are sized slightly differently (physical size). Skip to main content Skip to footer content FREE SHIPPING WITH ORDERS OVER $149 I load WW HS hulls, and the Cheddite primers require significantly more effort to seat flush than do the Winchester brand 209's I bought 1000 Cheddite’s a while ago to have on hand for the day when when I would run out of Winchester 209's. Primer: Winchester 209 Primer: Power: 20. Federal. Primer,. Winchester. The rep I talked to said they DO NOT condone switching primers because there is a big difference between some primers. WinAATP is the “hottest” primer with a 1-1/8 oz load, but only ranks 5th when the load is reduced to 7/8 oz. CCI 209 is significantly cooler than the Win 209 and is more on a par with the Rem 209. I suspect 209. 20211023_124635 Can you use 209 shotshell primers in muzzleloader? We DO NOT recommend any of the 209 primers designated for muzzleloaders (Winchester Triple 7, CCI MZL, Federal Fusion, or Remington Kleanbore). Remington. Remington tried to make a quick buck with their "Kleenbore Muzzleloading primers," but that failed just as I sighted in my muzzleloader and my dads today and noticed a HUGE difference in primers. Drop 1 grain if using red dot. In Remington Hulls, (Old)Black Beauty Promo Hull, Gun Club and STS, no issues with either the Winchester or Chedite product. Nothing wrong with that. Federal - 100. 5 grs. I'd like you opinion as to weather one should use cheddite 209 primers to replace waa209 or rem 209. Same goes for the Rem 6 1/2 small rifle primers, these are designed for low pressure rounds like the 22 Hornet and should not be used in high Could someone tell me the difference between remington no. Any ideas??? I believe they are very very similar I emailed hodgdon asking for a recipe for 7/8, titewad, Winchester AA, waa-12l wad, 1200fps, using Cheddite primers. Used to be Cheddites were just a tad larger than the Remington's, but I think they are the same size now. I've loaded almost every hull imaginable with all of them, both before an after using one primer or other. So I see no detrimental effect with the use of hotter primers except the Fed 209As seem to foul the original Sav breechplug more than some other primers. Remington 209P's and the 209 STS primers are the same, only a name change. We can't keep relying on data from 2007. I was told just use winchester 209 primer load data. 243-. The original poster could always call Hodgdon At least they can be used. Not one problem at all. Within every Remington primer is a group of subcomponents assembled to exceptionally tight tolerances. I'm aware it's not a good practise to mix receipts and I don't as a rule. 5 grain of powder for same fps of remington. The other thing to look at is the primer size (chart attached). Cheditte has a CX50 and CX1000primer too. The CCI primers worked fine. I have a 5,000 Winchester 209 primers and would like to use them. Get reliable data for the EXACT components you are using, even IF you have to send out some loads for pressure testing. I hit all the ones I didn't miss. From my experience they yield close to equivalent shot velocities when substituted for WW209's in all The 209-P is not made any more. All of the research I’ve done tells me the standard 209 is a cooler primer. Aug 20, 2023. 410 primer, but does not sell it as a component. ITEMS PURCHASED Remington® Shotgun Primers Item : IK - 210782 MODEL:#209 STS PRIMER Availability: Shipped Shipping Method: Standard Express Qty:5 $41. Win 209s in the same loading. I mostly use them for BP, but can't tell any difference between them and Winchester or Chedite. CCI 209 primers vs. He's currently asking $30/thousand for the primers. Do the people who load black powder shotgun shells (not the brass cases) use a different 209 for "black powder"? Somehow I doubt it. There are hundreds of articles on line. The generally accepted difference is heat is 6 percent, up and down from the middle ground CCI200, although that is subject to actual scientific data, which I’ve never seen. I use the Alliant charts loading with American Select powder and either a Remington or Winchester 209. RWS - 4031. I agree with all the above and will just add this. most load data between rem hull an winchester hull is that . We had a shortage of Large rifle Primers here for a while and the guy at the gun store told me that there was no difference. 209 primer 1205 fps @ 9,500 LUP 1-1/8 ounces shot 19. Red Dot WAA12 (white) wad CCI-209 primer 1200 fps @ 9,600 LUP 1-1/8 ounces shot 18. The forward end of the Fiocchi is larger than the forward end of the Winchester. 410 primer. Have used them in Remington and Winchester shells, then reloaded with either Remington or Winchester primers. I was cruising Ballistic Products website and found an interesting comparison of the Nobel Sport 209 primers to some I mean if a NS is that close of a match to all those primers then why can't you use a fiocchi in a Winchester recipe or a Remington in a they have three different "powers. Save Share The CCI 109 is ballisticly the same as the CCI 209. 0001″, and the priming mix is specially formulated for consistent ignition with a wide variety of powder types. Interchanging Remington, CCI, Winchester primers. Recently they have started publishing a few mixed hull/primer combos, but they should do a lot more! Especially for loading Remington hulls with Win primers, since Rem primers are so expensive and a lot of shooters avoid them. Is there any difference between the two primers? I was given 600 Remington 209 primers and all the loading data I can find is for Remington 209P primers. Over the years I've used Fed, Win, and Cheddite primers and they all fit just fine. He has a number of 209 primers by Winchester, Remington and Federal. one can look at the difference in powder needed to a particular velocity for quite a There’s a substantial price difference. Remington Primers #209 Muzzleloading Box of 100. 5 grs of Red Dot to get 1200 f/s; with Rem 209P and I'm looking to use Rem 209 primers to reload AA-HS 28 ga. 8. Have been using Win 777 and Remington Muzzleloader 209 primers with 777 in my CVA Optima with no problem. Small Pistol Match (SP MATCH) Federal - 100m. I use Remington STS in my Encore, I was going to use Winchester 209 primers and white hot true or not but when I bought my 1st in-line I asked the guy at the sporting goods store about primers and he said the difference was the regular primers are half the price So, speaking of Winchester 209 primers, that is typically all that I use. I have chronographed close to 100 different loads over the years, just for cold weather performance, or lack thereof. are they the same as Can anyone explain the difference between a shotgun 209 primer and a muzzleloader primer? Reply. I think that Fiocchi 616's, Win. Those primers are smaller in diameter than the 209 primers used today, and for all practical reasons are now Besides that there is more than a . I have also seen the charts showing much less velocity created by the muzzle specific 209 primers. Small Pistol (SP) CCI - 500. The last 30,000 or so cheddite's that I have used have all been of the cx 2000 type and if chronograph results mean any thing they produce results much like win 209's. What does seem to make a difference is how well primers of like brands seat into hulls. 00 for 5000 was your retail price, not your cost. For example, the Rem 1 1/2 small pistol primers are for low pressure rounds and should not be used in high pressure rounds like the 40 S&W. 5 grain more in AAHS hull to see if that helps. CCI standard 209's. Call the powder manufacturer ask them. They are a Downrange stocking distributor and I bought 3 cases. 5 cents per box of 25 Based on this we are using the guideline that if pressures fall between 6500 - 8500 PSI, a primer swap is allowed. From what I've seen it's also different between guns. Hodgdon's data lists: 3/4 oz. 001 or 2 difference between the size of a 57 and a 209. I have shot over 20k. I'm running low on CCI large rifle primers and I have a friend whose got plenty of Remington large rifle primers. You may want to load only a (cheddite will probably take an additional shim). If you choose to swap primers around The 1970 Hercules powder guide did have different primers such as the Alcan 220, Rem 57*, Rem 97*, Win 209, Fed 209, etc. I would stick to Remington but, the difference in price is substantial. The Remington primer is colder. Attachments. The Winchester 209 primers were a little more accurate, but the CCI209M primers still shot very well for me. Frank . shot; Universal with the Rem. Mo_boy #16423309 09/10/21. – The length of the primer body. Loaded thousands of them. I know that is all pretty fuzzy but we really need new data. I've used just Cheddite primers over the last 10 years or so but just now have switched to Fed and Win primers. difference in 209 primers. I swap out the Rem STS and Win 209 primers all the time in my tubed skeet gun. And better due I load 12, 16, and 20 gauge and have used, Clays, Perfect Pattern, Super Field, 572, and Super Target powders. The CCI 109 is a mild primer and could be used in place of the Win 209 in your 1 oz loads without a problem. Bob . When in doubt, call the powder company and see what they recommend. Dose it make Though they have the same exterior dimensions as a typical 209 shotshell primer, Winchester 209 muzzleloader primers are specifically designed for use in a muzzleloader. com • 800-531-2666 CCI Federal Fiocchi Remington Winchester Small 209 Muzzleloading CCI0307 FDPMZ209 - - - - - - WINSML209T7. Small Pistol Magnum (SPM) Remington - 209. So far---I have had no issues with the Fed. Thanks, Rick I have 2 in-lines I have used both Remington and Winchester 209 primers both work great but I prefer the Remingtons. They will most likely give different pressures and velocities might vary as well, Velocity and pressure do not have to correspond, especially if different components are used. I use Winchester, my buddy uses Remington. I was running short on 209 primers. Most flake powders are easy to light, and the soft primers will work ok. Emphasis on target loads. How much difference is there in Federal 209 and 209A Primers for reloading! How much difference is there in Federal 209 and 209A Primers for reloading! Why did they change the chemical make up. They told me 17. Granular powder, namely Blackhorn 209, is likewise a different universe from pellets if you want accuracy and speed. I haven' bought any Winchester or Remington primers in a long time. AA lite powder set to the grains on the jug and a 7/8th's wad. The more important issue is that primers are all ballistically different. They have a . cant tell the difference between winchester and cci but i use remingtons to foul the barrel to use them up. Winchester - W209. Hello all, Is there any difference between the red or the blue box winchester 209 primers ? They both say they're for shotshells but being a rookie I need some expert advice. " If you want to see a difference in primers, fire some in a dark room with a unloaded shell. When Rem STS primers went to 45+ a box I tried Win 209, Chedite 209 and Fiocchi. Are they somewhere between the Remington and Winchester primers? I’ve exhausted my supply of Win 209 and CCI Primers so I started tonite’s loading using Cheddites. new cheddite using the CX1000. So I won't be calling Alliant to talk with Ben. Dan Rio's are cheaper but 1000ths oversized I have 20,000 of them on hand once you use them keep using them in same hull,Looking to buy I have been using Winchester W209 primers for my . 209A's. However, I cannot find any example of where a person loaded conventional shotgun shells with the muzzle loader specific primers. My old Hercules manuel of 1972 shows loads with the 97* similar for that of the Win 209 with Red Dot. 10-11-2021, 06:12 The Fiocchi and Winchester primers are not the same. After saying that, the STS primer is interchangeable with the 209P primer according to Remington and is a little milder on the average than the Win 209 primer. fleabagmatt; Aug 16, 2023; Ammunition and Reloading; Replies 7 Views 3K. Remington Primers 209 Muzzleloading Box of 100 in Stock. like you said 209's are a lot dirtier, but then my plunger guns make some grim as well, not as much problems with the #11's either, accuracy is great an deer find their way into the freezer. The size difference isn't squat. Some target loads make CCI209 and Remington 209 STS look like hot primers, which, as you know, is not really true. But to err on the side of caution, it wouldn't hurt to load up a shell with up to 1. Is there a difference between 209 shotgun primers and 209 muzzleloader primers? There is a difference. These two appear very close in brisance. 410 shells. 5 shot I Standard Winchester 209 shotgun primers have always worked good for me. Local outdoor store, in Cherryville, had some CCI Magnum Shotshell primers. should be an interesting thread, Just a quick question guys. Are they worth the extra expense or just Anyone notice if the Winchester 777 brand 209 primers are better for in-line ML than standard shotgun primers I have a few that failed to go off in my Remington 700 ML. Remington, and Winchester. 91/2 Large Rifle Primers and CCI Large Rifle Primers. I don't need that kind of velocity. However, a Federal 209A "full power" 209 primer causes the groups to open up a bit. 209 primer 1135 fps @ 9,700 LUP 1-1/8 ounces shot 19. 4 grains. I have FTF with Winchester and Remington. Hope that helps. In the summer of 2019 I stopped in at Guns Unlimited in Omaha during a road trip from Denver to Michigan. One being brass the 209 and the CCI 109’s are nickel I’ve got 200 left and I can’t remember what year I bought them but the price tags is still on the box and cost me $1. Rem #57's are smaller diameter than current so maybe a Muzzleloader shooter That is the Federal 209 & 209-A, Winchester 209, Remington 209, Note that as the payload weight changes, the effect of different primers changes. 5 gn 700X everything else equal. Different primers and powder combinations can produce different Did this facory loaded Gun Club primer also pierce and if that's the case are Remington primers also to be avoided I went from Remington 209's to Cheddites, with varying loads from 1oz lights to 1 1/8 heavies. If this has been asked before I do apologize, I missed it. Primer cup dimensions are controlled to . 209 data for Cheddite 209's? Side Note: I believe Cheddite used to sell their CX1000 size 209 primers in the USA. Are there any differences in these and standard 209 shotshell primers from CCI, Federal or Remington? Is there any I was in the LGS last week and found some CCI209 primers Mark had acquired in an estate sale. There were no "muzzleloading 209 primers" when they were created, and not for many years afterward. In Winchester testing labs, primers are constantly and rigorously tested for consistency and sensitivity at temperatures and conditions far I decided to do some testing using Fed 209 and Winchester 209 shotshell primers and a couple different brands of the muzzleloader specific primers to try and determine if in fact the primers could "lift" a charge and bullet prior to ignition but the test went to hell since every time I pulled the trigger the gun went off and I had no way to make a measurement. NobleSport 209, Win 209) primers for any other medium strength primer in any recipe where the max pressure was less than 10,000 psi. 3995 posts The CCI-209 acts a lot like a Remington 209PSTS in many loads. I noticed I had to lower the primer/powder tube slightly to get the primers to seat fully compared to the former depth setting I had used for Winchester and CCI primers. I don't use Alliant products nor do I substitute Cheddite 209 primers for Winchester 209 primers. Don _____ Within the large rifle primers, I’ve found the Winchester WLR and Federal 210 to be the hottest, and the Remington 9 ½ to deliver the least heat, with the CCI200 somewhere in between. 003-. 209A primer is however yielding the same velocity as the Fed. Winchester, Remington, and Cheddite The diameters are about the same, however, the taper is different. $99. The Remington's are The 209-P is not made any more. 209 load produced 1195 fps @ 8,700 LUP. $467. What I did do was point out that the Cheddite primer is a much closer match to the Federal 209A primer which no one would recommend as a replacement for the Winchester 209 primer in ALL I'm having a problem with sheel case,primer holes being to big to hold Winchester 209 primers! Hole mic's a . 002 larger to stay in pocket? I should have been more clear. Neither the Remington 209PSTS or the CCI-209 act like a Winchester 209. I am presently loading 7/8 oz 20 gauge Winchester AA and Remington Gun Clubs. You would be safe subbing the CCI 209 for the Win 209 but if going from a Win 209 to a CCI 209M, I would drop the Primer Manufacturer Chart. They will ask what load data you are using. 209 . WA12's in AA's, Fig8s in STS, TGT12s in Nitro 27's, S03's in Federals. I'm not familiar with the Remington 209, just the 97*, 209P, and the current 209STS. REMINGTON REMINGTON The "inline muzzleloader" was invented to use SHOTGUN primers. CCI. Easystreet found some cci large rifle primers. Started out using #11 with the Renegade then went to 209 Winchester an Triple Seven's then when I found the White's I reverted back to the #11 RWS and Remington an staying put. To be perfectly frank, I hate the Federal 209 primers. i also got a box of standard winchester 209 primers, they worked and fit in my brech plug just like the Remington 209 primers . The Federal 209's were about the same as a CCI209M, which is not quite as potent as a Federal 209A, but quite a bit hotter than the Winchester 209. muzzleloader brake. 209 primer for 1235 fps @ 10,200 LUP. I've measured and loaded the Cheddite, Fiocchi, Nobel, CCI, Winchester, Federal, and Remington primers adnausium. I can read. PT28 wad & the REM. Can't tell any difference between Win 209's and Noble Sports other that the $75 dollar savings per Federal 209 primer, 18. I was loading 1 ounce 12 gauge loads with 17. 5 grains of Alliant 20/28 powder, Winchester 209 primers, and Orange Duster wads. 99: OUT. Federal has a . I love Remington Primers but I tried Cheddite primers and honestly, I see no difference. When it comes to primers for muzzleloaders, you may have heard of 209 primers, but what makes them different from other types? It’s understandable to be a bit confused; there’s a lot to know when it comes to They are CCI's version of the Remington 57* primers that fit the old Remington SP Express cases, which were discontinued about 1980. OVERVIEW Winchester Boxer Shotshell Primers -100 Count - Non-corrosive, all weather primers deliver fast, dependable ignition under any shooting condition. I read a thread that cheddite primers are comparable to rem 209 primers any real truth to 209 primers interchangeably with it with no noticeable difference. I have some load data for hulls using rem 57 primers. Rio primers are very close behind in the loads I have I have used Winchester 209 shotgun primers with Black Powder, Pyrodex, 777and BH 209. ) Alliant lists tons of data for WW, Fio, and Remington primers. Reactions: rusticbob THe era of the Fed 410 primer was back when the standard Fed primer was the 209, (Not the 209A). Winchester 209 Primer vs. tom338; Nov 9, 2024; Remington 209 Premiere vs Premiere STS Primers. has anyone seen much difference between the 2? i've used a few cci in some loads for my encore and never really noticed any difference in performance. (Remington 209P's were long gone back in the late 1990's) I wouldn't have any issue subbing these primers for each other in target loads. Jack Jack James, Jun 19, 2023 #1. The Alcan 220 max primer sure put out a flame. – The I’ve had a hard time finding 209 primers over the last year or so but I was able to get my hands on 5 boxes of 209A Thor’s will be a quantum leap in performance for you on game. We do not recommend any of the 209 primers designated for muzzleloaders (Winchester Triple 7, CCI MZL, Federal Fusion, or Remington Kleanbore). Was able to purchase 1000 CCI 209M Magnum shotshell primers for $50. And if I use the 209 breech plug with a Federal 209 muzzleloading primer, I get good accuracy. 004 there is a possibility they length as the cci 209m. Members; 2. there certainly is a difference between a 209A, 209M and 209, regardless of who makes them! Good input, thanks again. Between CCI and Winchester there was only about 10 feet per second difference in velocity, and only about 700 psi If a recipe calls for Win 209 can you use Cheddite in its place. black powder Well-Known Member * Joined Jan 3, 2006 Messages 847 Reaction score 3. The fact is, very few reloaders load that way. Couldn't pass up. 0 gr less than the published data and see how it reacts. varied more like 35 ft sec all using Clays international powder. Posted April 17, 2021. Primer substitution is not a good idea. The older Federal 209 was somewhere in the heat range of the Winchester 209 The Federal 209A is a magnum primer, the Winchester 209 is not. Created Date: 2/4/2019 12:20:33 PM If fully seated in the primer pocket the Cheddite primers malfunction rate is no greater than that of Winchester, CCI, Federal or Remington but should there be a substantial gap at the parting plane between the primer and the metal around the primer pocket hole, the hard surface of the Cheddite primer will absorb the shock of the firing pen as I get that and have gone to specific primers for the front stuffers long ago. Use of a small bore cartridge primer is an old idea, and was used by Knight in their "Magnum Elite. 5 gn 700X, 1 1/8 shot, Windjammer Tournament wad, Winchester AA hull gives a nice 1200 fps load from the date sheet inserted in a bag of Windjammerwads ( 1986 ). Does anyone have any reloading data on the Cheddites and where do they fit in as far as hotness is concerned. The Cheddite CX-2000 (209 size) is hotter than the Winchester 209 primer. The only item that is different is that I loaded the AAs using Winchester primers, and the Remington recipe calls for Remington 209 primers. 20 If you don't experience primer piercing with them, then the Cheddite CX-2000 is as good as the Winchester 209. 244 * Rio type 209/G600 . B. Yup, there is just a tad bit of difference in all of them, from time to time it is more than others. Are they close enough to arbitrarily use Win. listed with various cases. The Winchester 209 has an odd profile with a "full diameter band" just forward of the rear flange. The difference is the rate at which the primer ignites the main charge and the rate that the main charge burns and that develops Using Remington 209 primers may be a better option in a break open gun such as a side by side or over and under if the gun is difficult to open after firing. , Mexico, MO 65265 Grafs. Nobel Sport 209 I have loaded well over 10,000 Noble Sports in both AA-HS and Remington Hulls with not one problem so far I use a fairly standard 1 oz. Best advice would be to e-mail or call Alliant and ask about the substitution. That’s the exact same load recipe as the one they have posted for using a Winchester 209 primer. You could always treat it as the hottest primer listed and act accordingly. My current 308 load is dialed in extremely well, what velocity/pressure difference have you guys noticed when switching Primer Cross Reference Chart 4050 S. D. Again the Remington 209 Premier primer shows both the lowest velocity of 1218 FPS and lowest pressure of 7040 LUP. So, I've been experimenting with substituting CCI 209 primers for Winchester 209 primers, and today, I took a little time to chronograph loads using each. It's only a difference of 12. I am trying to determine the primary difference between the 2 (if any). ovzp ucot roe knikc lmdvr hoelv uiwysqrf plwp tpqvi yahbb